The beauty test

Kathleen Baird-Murray puts lip glosses, eyeshadows and concealers to the test

Cult product

Eve Lom

Rescue Mask, £25. 0207 299 4940

The clay-like base is fantastic for drawing out spots and great for sensitive skin. Come on and rescue me!

Most wanted

Chanel

in 217 Splendeur, £12, 0207 493 3836

A hot pink to make your heart sing. Fantastic on fingers or toes.

Lip glosses good for under 40s

Chanel

Glossimer in 93, 5.5g, £14, 020 7493 3836

This one's great, very Paris Hilton.

4 stars

Lancôme

in 021, 6ml, £15.50, widely available

Less scary on than in the tube. Lots of dazzle for disco-ball lips.

4 stars

Boots 17

in Raspberry Cooler, 8ml, £3.79, available in Boots

Very wearable despite bubblegum shade in tube. Smells good enough to eat.

4 stars

Barbara Daly for Tesco

See-through Lip Glaze, 8ml, £4.50, 0800 505 555

Smells good but too sticky (one for the kids?) Very natural.

3 stars

Plump and shimmer lip glosses

Freeze 24/7

Plump Lips in Arctic Glaze, 8ml, £25, 020 8740 2085

Fab colour, great plumping , but too much packaging.

4 stars

Soap and Glory

Sexy Mother Pucker in Nude, 7ml, £7.50, www.boots.com

Really works. Tingles but great colour.

Too Faced

Glamour Gloss in Girls on Film in 61, 3.8ml, £11, 0845 070 8090

Fantastic. Love the furry nozzle-thing. Easy to apply, not too pouty.

4 stars

Clinique

Full Potential Lips in 06 Mimosa, 4.7ml, £12, 0870 034 25666

A beautiful shade but far too sticky and glossy.

2 stars

Compact foundation

Prescriptives

Anywear Multi-Finish Compact Foundation SPF12 in Gold 07, 30ml, £25, 0870 0342566

Lovely sandy colour. Perfect if you like yours powdery.

4 stars

Shiseido

Compact Foundation in 060 Natural Deep Ochre, 13g, £28.50, 0207 313 4774

Light texture, a bit dull.

4 stars

Body Shop

All in One Face Base in 02, 10g, £10.50, 01903 844 554

A little grey and too powdery.

3 stars

NARS

Powder Foundation SPF12 in Budapest, 12g,£34.50, 0870 8377377

Light coverage, good mirror but measly sponge.

3 stars

Eyeshadows good for under 40s

NARS

in Night Flight, 3g, £15.50, 0870 837 7377

Divine shade of inky blue, not too sparkly, fantastic for big rock-star eyes.

5 stars

Colour Addict

in Neptune, 2g, £10, www.vitaliberata.com

Such a pretty green, line with a brush if you're worried about getting shimmer stuck in creases.

4 stars

Stila

Eyeshadow in Kitten, 2.6g, £9.50, 01273 408 800

This is better for 20-somethings as the shimmer collects in even the most invisible of wrinkles.

3 stars

Bobbi Brown

Surf and Sand Eye Palette, 4g, £35, 08700342566

Looks so pretty in the palette but there's too much shimmer.

2 stars

Neutral eyeshadows

By Terry

in 1, 2g, £20, 020 8740 2085

Fine powder texture in a must-have colour. Doesn't sit in creases.

4 stars

Sisley

Eyeshadow in Vanilla, 1.5g, £19, 020 7591 6380

Good base for eyeliner or highlighter, opening up the eye area.

4 stars

Rimmel

Metallic Cream Shadow in 011 Portobello, 3.5g, £3.49, widely available.

Love the pretty champagne gold but it migrates around the eyes.

3 stars

Bobbi Brown

in Bone, 3.2g, £13.50, 08700342566

Good colour for base or highlighting but doesn't last very long.

3 stars

Creamy concealers

Shu Uemura

Pro Concealer in Medium, 4g, £14, 020 7240 7635 Good texture for really big spots and bad shadows .

4 stars

Laura Mercier

Secret Camouflage in SC3, 7.7g, £25, 0870 8377377

A little chalky but has a good consistency for those who like blending, or need heavier coverage.

3 stars

Shiseido

Concealer stick in Medium, 3g, £17.50, 020 7313 4774

This concealer feels a little bit chalky.

3 stars

Pout

Blendable Concealer in Medium Underwear, 3g (2x1.5g), £15 , 0207 379 0379

Doesn't give enough coverage for me, but then everyone's different.

3 stars

Liquid concealers

Dr Hauschka

Concealer in 03, 2.5ml, £14, 01386 792 642

Better than I expected from a skincare range. This feels fresh and has a great applicator .

4 stars

Clinique

Airbrush concealer in 02, 1.5ml, £15, 0870 03425666

With practice,the brush gets easier to use . It has a silicone texture which blends well over foundation.

4 stars

Guerlain

Issima in Beige Naturel 20, 1.5ml, £24, 01932 233887

This doesn't give enough coverage for my liking.

3 stars

Nars

Eyebrightener in Praline, 1.5ml, £19 Selfridges 0870 8377377

This doesn't conceal enough, doesn't sit easily on the skin and feels patchy.

2 stars


Your IP address will be logged

The beauty test

This article was first published on guardian.co.uk at 17.58 BST on Sunday April 15 2007. It appeared in the Observer on Sunday April 15 2007 on p66 of the Features section. It was last updated at 17.58 BST on Monday April 16 2007.

Most viewed on guardian.co.uk

  1. Loading …

Guardian Jobs

UK

Browse all jobs

USA

  • Travel Nurse- Psychiatric

    anywhere you go in the state, louisiana's heritage figures prominently -- it's visible in the architecture, arts, ambience and, of course, the people.. la.

  • Social Work Faculty

    year, christian liberal arts school affiliated with the free methodist church. this community of learners celebrates the heritage of an evangelical wesleyan... . mi.

  • Physician - Family Practice with no OB

    j. boyd museum, the heritage museum and the stephen f... by the  arts council, the festival is an annual source of entertainment, enjoyment and education with arts... . nc.

Browse all jobs